Vermont’s $80M IT overhaul pause lengthens as ‘shocking’ audit finds more concerns


Theo Wells-Spackman is a Report for America corps member who reports for VTDigger.
Vermont’s wide-reaching $80 million IT modernization project has effectively been on pause since April.
Now, a new audit has branded the state’s progress on the issue “unsatisfactory,” and Gov. Phil Scott’s administration is setting aside six more months to prepare for the transition and address the sweeping concerns outlined by the independent report. Estimates of the project’s overall cost, previously hovering at $70 million, have also ticked up, according to state officials.
The yearslong project, which is among the most expensive such undertakings in the state’s recent history, seeks to replace five existing state IT systems, including human resources and finance software, with the multi-use platform Workday. Crucial questions about how the new system will replace and interact with the old state software, as well as the timeline and cost for the effort, “remain unanswered,” the auditors said.
Sen. Rob Plunkett, D-Bennington, who chairs the Joint Information Technology Oversight Committee, called the findings “shocking” in a meeting of the panel Friday.
“How can you help us, like, not be freaking out about this?” asked Rep. Monique Priestley, D-Bradford, of state officials at the meeting. “It just feels like we’re — we’re doing this over and over again.”
Indeed, it’s not the first time an independent analyst has raised the alarm over the project’s framing.
Lisa Gauvin, an IT consultant for the state’s Legislative Joint Fiscal Office, told lawmakers 18 months ago that the Agency of Digital Services had not done sufficient analysis to determine which functions can and cannot be replaced by Workday.
Then-Digital Services Secretary Denise Reilly-Hughes disagreed at the time, saying that while there were always unknowns in the early phases of such an undertaking, her team had done multiple “gap analyses” to confirm the new system’s ability to fill the state’s needs.
In April, officials shifted their approach to implementing Workday — potentially causing delays and cost increases, they said — and paused their work on the project.
Reilly-Hughes left her role in mid-October to take a job at Microsoft.
READ MORE
Projects like this one generally take states between two and four years to complete, according to Jim Kreiser, a principal at CliftonLarsonAllen, the financial consulting firm who conducted this month’s audit at the request of State Auditor Doug Hoffer. That in itself makes Vermont, already about six years into its modernization effort according to Gauvin, something of an “outlier,” he said.
Given the audit’s findings, the state’s basis for selecting Workday may itself be in question, Kresier added.
“You may be at an inflection point of deciding: Have we even made the right decision?” he said.
Sean Brown, the state’s deputy secretary of administration, said his team was largely in agreement with many of the audit’s findings. Several areas of the project, he said, carry “substantial risk” currently.
Brown said the next step would be a 24-week period of work to address the audit’s concerns and prepare to implement the new system. At that point, he said, officials will “come back with a proposed timeline to restart the project.”
All parties agreed that the stakes are high. Kreiser’s team said bungling the new software’s implementation could corrupt data, cause costly delays and disrupt the normal functioning of government.
Other states have experienced significant bumps in the road implementing Workday, including Rhode Island and Oregon.
Priestley also raised questions about whether it would be responsible for lawmakers to continue funding the project when so many key factors are up in the air. In order to greenlight more money, she said over text Friday, she would need to see a detailed plan about how the new system would replace particular functions performed by the old ones and ensure access to existing data.
“From my perspective, we’re past the point of assurances,” Priestley said. “The bar is high for a reason.”
The Legislature has approved roughly $25 million so far, of which the state had spent about $17 million at the end of October, according to Chrissy Gilhuly, a spokesperson for the Agency of Administration.
“Every time there’s a delay in this project,” said Gauvin at Friday’s meeting, “that’s another cost.”
Kreiser said the project’s budget estimates are “certainly part of what needs to be reevaluated” in the coming months.
Read the story on VTDigger here: Vermont’s $80M IT overhaul pause lengthens as ‘shocking’ audit finds more concerns.
Ver nota original ↗
¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?
