Las Vegas Review-Journal — News
20/11/2026 21:56

Billion-dollar water rights ruling could ‘plunge the state into crisis,’ lawyer says

A single ruling this week may have changed Nevada water law forever.

District Judge Mark Denton, in one of his final acts before retiring from the bench, ruled against the state of Nevada on Wednesday in a high-profile water rights case over determinations by the state engineer that plans to build a new city northeast of Las Vegas could not proceed.

“It throws everything I’ve known and understood about Western water law into total chaos,” said Debbie Leonard, a Northern Nevada water attorney at the firm Leonard Law who wasn’t involved in the case. “It upends everything. It’s really hard for me to get my head around a decision like this and not just be appalled.”

Attorneys for Coyote Springs owners and property rights advocates say such concerns are overblown and that the ruling can help guide future decisions about water regulation.

In the precedent-setting decision, Denton ruled that the state’s approach to managing groundwater in the area that rendered the development plans useless was an “unconstitutional taking” of private property.

A jury will determine how much state taxpayers will have to pay in damages in the next phase of the trial; the developer is seeking $600 million, plus interest and attorneys’ fees.

One of the state’s attorneys, Laura FitzSimmons, said that math works out to well over $1 billion.

“This decision is unfathomable,” FitzSimmons said. “No court in any state or anywhere in this country has ever found that a water permit is a property right that requires compensation.”

And now, after potentially cashing in more than $1 billion in settlement money from state taxpayers after attorneys’ fees and interest, the land where developers envisioned the city of Coyote Springs appears to be getting a second act.

Nevada energy regulators awarded conditional approval for an 8,177-acre, 1,200-megawatt solar project in mid-October, pending additional approvals needed from the state, Lincoln County and the Federal Aviation Administration.

If constructed as proposed by the Reno-based company Estuary Power, it could become one of the nation’s largest solar projects by size and power generation.

Massive solar project could be built

A solar farm is a far cry from the original plan for Coyote Springs, once planned to be twice the size of Summerlin with as many as 160,000 homes paired with golf courses and hotel-casinos. The land straddles Clark and Lincoln Counties and is now owned by the California developers Albert and Thomas Seeno.

As recently as 2022, the developers’ general counsel told the Las Vegas Review-Journal that they saw a path forward for one of the proposed subdivisions of 575 homes. But attorney Mark Hutchison, who represented the Seenos in this water rights case, said in a Thursday interview that his clients have no plans to resurrect the original vision for a city.

“The answer is it’s just solar,” Hutchison said. “And right now, it’s just an option agreement.”

But it appears that is a pretty solid option under heavy consideration.

NV Energy, the utility that supplies power to the Las Vegas Valley, entered into a power-purchase agreement for 600 megawatts from the first half of the project’s solar panels. A utility spokeswoman said the agreement is pending approval from state regulators, and that it would buy power for 25 years and a battery storage system for 20 years.

Public meeting minutes show that the Lincoln County Commission unanimously approved the development in early October. The Federal Aviation Administration’s records reflect no evidence of an approval that would be needed for the solar project’s second half of construction and the state has issued no other necessary permits.

Patrick Donnelly, Great Basin director of the nonprofit Center for Biological Diversity, said the land is intact habitat for the Mojave desert tortoise. The animals, though kept as pets in Clark County, are listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act — and utility-scale solar remains a concern.

Donnelly said that climate change modeling has shown that the tortoise will leave fast-warming areas in Southern California and will seek refuge at cooler spots in Nevada.

“That means places like the areas around Mesquite, around Overton and Coyote Springs Valley,” Donnelly said. “These are all essential desert tortoise habitat in a climate change scenario.”

A hindrance for future developers?

Whatever may come of the Seenos land, prominent lawyers are concerned about the precedent the case will set.

Leonard sees parallels to the high-profile case where the Nevada Supreme Court agreed that the city of Las Vegas engaged in a “taking” of private property from a developer who sought to build homes on the Badlands Golf Course in Summerlin. City officials denied or restricted the development several times and the city agreed to a settlement that cost it $286 million.

In that case, Leonard helped represent the city. Leonard said she believes the court’s finding in the Badlands lawsuit “rolled out the red carpet” for Coyote Springs to revive its takings case, which was first filed in 2020.

And now, Leonard said the state engineer is unlikely to issue new permits or what are known as extensions of time that allow room for developers to hold onto their water rights while they develop water resources over many years.

“I don’t think it’s hyperbole to say that this is going to plunge the state into crisis over economic development and water resources,” Leonard said. “Now, the state engineer now is not going to want to grant a single application.”

She added: “If the state engineer is not going to grant extensions of time, because doing so is basically creating an entitlement to claim a taking, and it’s going to shut down that office so terribly that nothing is going to be able to get done.”

Tom Romero, a UNLV law professor, wrote in an email that he agrees that the decision puts the state’s ability to grant and administer water rights into flux.

The Nevada Supreme Court in 2024 upheld the state’s decision to merge several connected water basins in the area into one “superbasin.” Romero said it’s not clear whether officials should keep managing the region under that regime.

“The trial court’s opinion seems to suggest that this is the case and that failure to do so, is a taking,” Romero wrote. “This, however, would make moot all of the power affirmed in the (Nevada Supreme Court) case.”

‘My message to taxpayers’

Hutchison, the developers’ attorney who served as the state’s Republican lieutenant governor from 2015 to 2019, said he understands that the price tag may seem significant to taxpayers.

But he says the Seenos ran out of legal remedies and now are owed something in return. Denton’s ruling is a strong showing of how the judicial branch should hold regulators accountable, Hutchison said.

“My message to taxpayers is that this is the way that the United States Constitution is structured to hold government accountable,” Hutchison said.

Damien M. Schiff, an environmental lawyer with the libertarian-leaning public interest firm the Pacific Legal Foundation, called the ruling a rare win for property rights.

While he agrees it is a precedent-setting decision, Schiff said he does not think it will be a “radical bellwether” for how the state will change its approach to its regulation of water. He sees the facts of the case as narrow.

“To anyone who’s concerned about some threat to the ability of government to regulate water consumption, especially in arid states like Nevada, I would say that that I think that concern would be misplaced,” Schiff said.

Schiff said taxpayers may have valid concerns about how this case could be applied to others in the future. However, he said the decision is a mandate for policy change, not an indictment of the case’s merits.

“But the remedy is not to allow property owners to go uncompensated and to have their wrongs unaddressed, but rather to have this decision then inform government regulation going forward,” Schiff said.

The state’s legal team hasn’t decided whether it will immediately file for relief from the Nevada Supreme Court or wait until the trial’s second phase wraps up to file an appeal, said FitzSimmons, who worked alongside the Nevada Attorney General’s office in the case. A spokesman for the attorney general declined to comment on the implications of the ruling.

“This is a catastrophe for Nevada,” FitzSimmons said.

Because of Denton’s retirement, a new judge will be assigned to oversee the second phase of the trial, where a jury will decide damages. It’s not yet certain who that will be or how long the second phase may take.

Contact Alan Halaly at [email protected]. Follow @AlanHalaly on X.

📄 Contenido indexado automáticamente. No es de autoría de altabusqueda.com; los derechos pertenecen a su fuente: Las Vegas Review-Journal — News.
Ver nota original ↗
🤖 Profundizá esta noticia con OIMA (IA)

¿Querés un resumen rápido de esta noticia, hecho por nuestra IA?

Respuestas de OIMA · IA, sobre esta noticia · Abrir OIMA Chat ↗
💬 0

Comentarios

También te puede interesar

Faith Lutheran defeats Bishop Manogue to win 5A state football title
Las Vegas Review-Journal — News
Faith Lutheran claimed the 5A state football championship Friday at Allegiant Stadium by defeating Bishop Man…
Roblox faces another lawsuit alleging failures to protect minors
Las Vegas Review-Journal — News
A California teen and her mother are suing Roblox, alleging the gaming platform failed to protect her from a …
Raiders owner Mark Davis has biting assessment of ‘Madden’
Las Vegas Review-Journal — News
Las Vegas Raiders owner Mark Davis is not happy with the script in the new “Madden” movie.
Crews to wait until after Thanksgiving to complete airport tunnel repaving
Las Vegas Review-Journal — News
Reid airport officials considered closing traffic lanes in the Airport Connector tunnel for a repaving projec…
College football betting, predictions: Big Ten offers mixed bag in Saturday games
Las Vegas Review-Journal — News
Ohio State has lost three games, and coach Ryan Day is being exposed again, but the Buckeyes remain in the Co…
Las Vegas Grand Prix Day 2: Stars are out as skies clear for Friday practice laps
Las Vegas Review-Journal — News
Keanu Reeves and Colin Farrell were spotted Friday at the Formula 1 Las Vegas Grand Prix. Review-Journal repo…